74HC164D vs 74HC154D,653

Cette comparaison détaillée des composants 74HC164D et 74HC154D,653 vous offre un aperçu précieux de leurs spécifications et caractéristiques clés. Nous abordons en détail les facteurs importants, notamment la conformité RoHS, le statut REACH, la série, le mode de montage, le type de boîtier et d'autres caractéristiques pertinentes. La présentation côte à côte des différences simplifie la sélection des composants et vous permet de choisir plus facilement la meilleure option pour votre application spécifique.

Technical review by ETEI Component Engineering Source: manufacturer documentation

Replacement verdict

Not a drop-in replacement

The 74HC164D and 74HC154D,653 are functionally unrelated logic ICs and cannot serve as substitutes for one another. The 74HC164D is an 8-bit serial-in/parallel-out shift register, while the 74HC154D,653 is a 4-to-16 line decoder/demultiplexer. Their internal architectures, pin functions, and intended applications differ fundamentally, so neither device can directly replace the other in an existing design without significant circuit redesign.

Different logic function Different pin function Different input/output topology Different application role

Parts at a glance

Key differences

Rows are prioritized by design impact. Highlighted values require attention during substitution.

Key electrical and mechanical differences between the two devices

Parameter 74HC164D 74HC154D,653 Why it matters
Logic Function 8-bit serial-in/parallel-out shift register 4-to-16 line decoder/demultiplexer The core logic function determines whether the devices are functionally interchangeable; these two perform entirely different operations.
Number of Outputs 8 16 Output count affects how many loads or lines the device can drive in a system.
Number of Inputs 2 (data + clock) 4 (address) plus 2 enable inputs Input count and type dictate the control interface and addressing capability of the device.
Output Type Push-pull (totem-pole) Active-low outputs Output polarity and drive style determine compatibility with downstream logic and loads.
Package SO-14 (SOIC-14) SO-24 (SOIC-24) Package footprint and pin count must match the PCB layout for a drop-in replacement.
Pin Count 14 24 Different pin counts mean the devices are not pin-compatible and cannot be swapped directly.
Supply Voltage Range 2 V to 6 V 2 V to 6 V Both operate over the standard HC-family supply range, so voltage compatibility is equivalent.
Logic Family 74HC (high-speed CMOS) 74HC (high-speed CMOS) Same logic family ensures comparable input/output thresholds and noise margins.
Propagation Delay (typical) Approximately 14 ns at 5 V Approximately 15 ns at 5 V Propagation delay influences maximum operating speed and timing margins in synchronous designs.
Primary Application Serial-to-parallel data conversion, LED driving, I/O expansion Address decoding, memory/chip-select decoding, demultiplexing Intended application highlights that these parts serve fundamentally different roles and are not substitutes.

Need help validating a replacement?

Send your BOM and application constraints for technical and sourcing review.

Full specification comparison

Use manufacturer datasheets as the final authority.

Specification 74HC164D 74HC154D,653
Supplier - Rochester Electronics, LLC
Series 74HC 74HC
Part Status Active Active
Type - Decoder/Demultiplexer
Circuit - 1 x 4:16
Independent Circuits - 1
Current - Output High Low - 5.2mA, 5.2mA
Voltage Supply Source - Single Supply
Voltage - Supply 2V ~ 6V 2V ~ 6V
Operating Temperature -40°C ~ 125°C -40°C ~ 125°C
Mounting Type Surface Mount Surface Mount
Logic Type Shift Register -
Output Type Push-Pull -
Number of Elements 1 -
Number of Bits per Element 8 -
Function Serial to Parallel -

Frequently asked questions

What are the primary functional differences between the 74HC164D and the 74HC154D,653?

The 74HC164D is an 8-bit serial-in/parallel-out shift register, while the 74HC154D,653 is a 4-to-16 line decoder/demultiplexer. The 74HC164D shifts serial data into eight parallel outputs, whereas the 74HC154D decodes a 4-bit binary input into one of sixteen mutually exclusive active-LOW outputs.

Are the 74HC164D and 74HC154D,653 pin-compatible?

No. The 74HC164D is typically supplied in a 14-pin SOIC package, while the 74HC154D,653 is supplied in a 24-pin SOIC package. They have different pin counts, pin functions, and PCB land patterns, so they are not pin-compatible or directly interchangeable.

Can the 74HC164D and 74HC154D,653 operate from the same supply voltage?

Yes. Both devices are 74HC-family CMOS logic parts and are specified for a nominal supply voltage range of 2.0 V to 6.0 V, with 5 V being the most common operating voltage. However, individual datasheet limits and timing parameters should always be verified for the specific manufacturer and operating conditions.

What is the difference in output count and output type between these two devices?

The 74HC164D provides eight parallel outputs that follow the serial input data and are not mutually exclusive. The 74HC154D,653 provides sixteen active-LOW outputs, of which only one is asserted at a time based on the 4-bit address input, making it suitable for decoding and demultiplexing applications.

Which device is better suited for expanding microcontroller I/O?

The 74HC164D is typically used to expand outputs serially, requiring only two control lines (data and clock) to drive eight outputs. The 74HC154D,653 is used to select one of sixteen outputs from a 4-bit address, which is useful for address decoding or chip-select generation rather than general-purpose I/O expansion.

Do both devices have the same logic family and input threshold characteristics?

Yes. Both are 74HC high-speed CMOS devices, so they share standard 74HC input threshold ratios and CMOS-compatible input/output characteristics when operated at the same supply voltage. Exact switching thresholds, propagation delays, and drive currents should be confirmed from the respective manufacturer datasheets.

Can the 74HC164D be used as a drop-in replacement for the 74HC154D,653 in an existing design?

No. Because the two devices have different functions, pin counts, packages, and output logic, a direct drop-in replacement is not possible. Any substitution would require a complete redesign of the surrounding circuitry, including pin mapping, control signals, and output loading considerations.